I.
History of Agriculture
A. The crop plants and animals that form
the main components of modern agro ecosystems had their
origin in the natural ecosystems from which humans originally
gathered food and fiber. Humans, flowering plants and herbivorous
insects coexisted peacefully until about 10,000 years ago.
Then the human perspective on the plant eating habits of
insects changed once and for all. Concurrently on at least
four continents, humans hit upon the idea that growing plants
was a far more reliable way to obtain food than gathering
plants.
Thus, agriculture was invented.
B. This constitutes the first Agricultural
Revolution. The first plants to be domesticated were the
cereals, corn in the Americas, rice in Southeast Asia, wheat
and barley in Near East and sorghum in Africa.
C. May be started when a hunter-gatherer
tossed a handful of seed or grain from a plant into a garbage
pile. In the high nutrient environment the seed germinated
and some genius saw the answer to the problem of finding
enough food to eat.
D. For the first time in human existence,
people could generate a surplus of food-more than they could
eat in a short period of time. Surplus could be stored in
anticipation of hard times ahead. This allowed people to
abandon nomadic lifestyle and to settle in one place in
larger numbers. Surpluses of grain also meant that domestic
animals could be maintained year round and a regular source
of meat and dairy products improved people's diets.
E. Breeding of plants, either deliberate
or accidental, led to establishment of traits that were
desirable from both a farmer's and an insect's point of
view.
1. Dispersal bred out, so seeds stayed on stem instead of
falling and scattering.
2. Growth and development synchronized so harvesting could
be done in short period.
3. Edible seeds got larger and more numerous on each stem.
. In addition, the habits of agriculture
were favorable to an insect.
1. Crop plants were irrigated and fertilized, so from the
insects perspective water and nitrogen limitations on the
nutritional suitability of plants were reduced.
2. Crop plants were raised as monocultures, so there were
large amounts of single host plants available.
3. Because of E and F, Insect populations could increase
to levels without precedent in the natural world.
G. Second Agricultural Revolution did nothing
to reduce the problem. With the beginning of the Renaissance,
world exploration introduced peoples of all countries to
new and different crop plants.
Plants were exchanged and established in far distant
Places. As cultures acquired new foods, a number of insects
associated with these Crops were transported along with
them.
A good example is the cabbage white butterfly, first introduced
into N. A. from Europe about 1860. A ubiquitous pest of
cabbage, broccoli family. Many times crops were introduced
without some of their pest insects but pests were introduced
much later. The Hessian fly, a serious pest of wheat was
brought in straw used as animal bedding by troops in the
Revolutionary war. The cereal leaf beetle, another pest
of wheat was brought in around 1958.
A. Today, hundreds of plant species are producing products
of economic importance in virtually every nation and as
a consequence, herbivory by insects has far greater economic
importance than ever before. As a percentage of insect species,
the number of pest species is actually low. In North America,
it has been estimated that 150-200 insect species frequently
cause serious damage and 6000 or so are sometimes pests
but rarely cause severe damage. These numbers are a small
fraction of the nearly 90,000 species of insects in North
America north of Mexico. A similar proportion prevails worldwide.
However small the proportion, the economic consequences
are severe. $6.5 billion in losses in US in 1988. Estimates
of the pest problem on a world scale suggest that without
insect pests, world food production could be increased by
about a third.
II. What is a pest?
A. Biologically speaking, there is nothing
that defines a pest. Two similar insects may have almost
identical biological patterns and even be in the same family,
yet one will be considered a pest and the other not, because
one attacks humans or something valued by humans. Example:
the Colorado potato beetle defoliates the potato and the
dock beetle defoliates dock with equal regularity. That
the former is a pest and the latter not reflects the value
we place on potato and our disinterest in dock. With this
subjective view of an organisms place in nature in mind,
the definition of a pest is any organism that annoys humans.
B. Pest status can change.
C. Pest problems are population problems
1. Some pest problems are natural in origin.
Large numbers of mosquitoes and biting flies emerge at the
same time in areas where climate synchronizes their development.
2. Humans also do things that end up making
pests-"non-natural" origin.
III. How to make a pest insect
A. To understand how an insect becomes
a pest, it is important to understand a little about how
insect populations are regulated in natural ecosystems
B. A population is a group of individuals
of the same insect species living in the same place at the
same time. Communities are groups of populations (all living
things) in an area. An ecosystem is a community of living
organisms (plant, animal, bacterial, fungal, protozoa) and
the physical/chemical environment around them.
C. Let's theorize about the growth of an insect population.
1. There are many factors that exert natural control on
population sizes.
a. First, note that for any given species, populations change
in size over time.Primary factors affecting population numbers
are:
1). births and immigration which increase the size of a
population
2). and deaths and emigration which decrease its size.
b. The resulting average population size varies widely with
species and with locality.
Insect species have a characteristic abundance. This refers
to the approximate upper and lower limits of densities at
which insects typically occur and values may vary by two
or three orders of magnitude (100-1000). Some species, like
mound-building termites live in populations containing millions
of individuals, but others, like some populations of butterflies
may have only a few dozen individuals. There are several
aspects of reproduction that determine how fast populations
can increase in size and how large populations can grow.
2. How many offspring that can be produced each time an
insect reproduces.
a. Female German cockroach can put 30-48 eggs into each
egg capsule she produces. The population down the street
may produce 30 while the ones in the apartment next door
may produce 48.
b. Termite queens may produce several hundred eggs/day.
c. Tsetse fly may produce 1 live young every 2-3 weeks.
3. How many times an insect can reproduce over its lifespan.
German cockroaches produce an average of 5 ootheca but more
prolific individuals may produce twice that number.
4. The age at sexual maturity or generation time can have
a big impact on the rate at which a population grows. Generation
time is the time it takes to go from egg to egg. Mice reproduce
at 18 days, dogs and cats at 7 months and humans at 14 years.
Think how many litters a cat can have by the time a person
figures out what's going on.
a. By the way, the record is 420 kittens by Dusty of Texas
between 1935 and 1952. The record of humans is 69 (16 twins,
7 triplets, 4 quadruplets).
b. Some fly species have generation times of less than a
week.
5. Entomologists love these sorts of calculations. Estimates
on the number of offspring a pair of houseflies can produce
in a year led to one controversy. L.O. Howard calculated
that if the fly began producing eggs in January, by September
15, there would be 5,598,720,000,000 flies, enough to cover
the earth to a depth of 47 feet. In 1964, these figures
were challenged by Harold Oldroyd who recalculated that
a layer of such thickness would cover only an area the size
of Germany, but "that is still a lot of flies".
C. Since we are not ankle-deep in house
flies, something in nature must keep populations in check.
That something is the environment. Any given environment
only has enough resources to support a limited number of
individuals of one species indefinitely. This number is
the carrying capacity of the environment, representing the
upper limit to the population.
D. Two kinds of environmental factors limit population growth.
1. Density dependent factors
2. Density independent factors
E. Density-dependent factors become more
severe as populations increase in size. Density-dependent
factors are usually biological in origin and include things
like competition for food and shelter, predation and parasitism,
and disease. 1. Competition for food and shelter. Plant
feeding insects compete for foliage or fruit to eat and
for places to lay their eggs. The greater the number of
competitors, the more intense the competition. This type
of interaction can be at the intraspecific level but if
the needs of two different species overlap (e.g. food is
same), then interspecific competition will ensue. If two
species are competing for the same food, then usually competitive
exclusion will occur, where one species will win out over
the other
2. Some parasitoids and predators move into areas when prey
become more abundant, often attracted by chemicals produced
by the prey. Some predators increase rate of killing of
particular prey species as prey increase. May result from
increased efficiency of predation from learning or greater
ease of encountering closely aggregated prey.
3. The more crowded individuals are, the greater the chances
for a sick individual to come into contact with and infect
others. Insects suffer from diseases caused by protozoa,
bacteria, viruses, fungi and nematode worms. Interest in
pathogenic microbes associated with insects has largely
been focused on their potential for use in biological control.
F. The second group of factors acts independently
of the size of the populations and these are called density
independent factors. Density independent factors are usually
abiotic (the physical and chemical features of the environment).
1. Temperature is very important in determining the range
and population size of insects.
a. Insects are poikilothermic-cold-blooded so body temperature
is usually same as ambient temperature. For every insect
species, there is a defined range of temperatures within
which it is able to survive. The range of tolerance varies
from species to species, within a species and with the physiological
state of the individual. Many insects can survive much lower
temperatures in the fall and winter. The range lies between
0 and 50 C with an optimal range for most species of 22
to 38 C. (There are some crickets that survive much greater
temperatures, some firebrats as well. A clip in Alien Empire).
b. Temperature affects how quickly eggs develop and the
rate of larval and pupal development. It thus affects how
many generations per year can be produced. Number of generations
often varies between the northern and southern regions of
an insect's range. Temperature is critical in monitoring
what will happen for many field crop pests.
2. Moisture.
a. Water content of insects varies from 50-90% of total
body weight. Soft bodied insects like caterpillars have
large amounts of waters. There is an optimal moisture range
in which a given species thrives. Low environmental moisture
(rainfall, humidity, available surface water) can cause
mortality due to desiccation. Very wet conditions can favor
the spread of viral, fungal and bacterial diseases and sometimes
can cause drowning. Insects are often very small and a drop
of water in a raindrop can represent a serious problem for
them (e.g. dodging them in flight and getting stuck in surface
tension of a drop).
b. High humidity will affect feeding and reproductive behavior
of many insects. For example, when humidity is above 88%,
the tsetse fly does not feed on vertebrate hosts.
G. Stability of natural ecosystems.
1. Species that display population oscillations of great
amplitude are referred to as unstable. Communities in which
the populations of some species oscillate widely are likewise
called unstable. Community stability may be related to diversity
and instability to lack of diversity. For example, in natural
systems, population outbreaks occur much more frequently
in simple ecosystems like the boreal forests, where there
are relatively few species of trees.
IV. So, given all of these mechanisms that kill insects
or limit their reproductive success,
how and why do insects become pests?
A. We as humans create insect pests
by:
1. Manipulation of the environment
2. Inadvertent transport of insect across geographical barriers
3. Through use of insecticides
4. Economic expectations of a given crop
B. Manipulation of the environment
1. Introduction of new host plants or large monocultures
of plants. Quite often insects that feed on foliage of native
plants switch over to related introduced crop plants and
respond to the increased food supply with a large increase
in population. Competition for food and shelter is reduced.
2. Prime example is the Colorado potato beetle as a major
pest Leptinotarsa decimlineata lived in the Rocky mountains
north of Mexico and fed on wild buffalo bur, a member of
the Solanaceae plant family. Prior to 1865, Native Americans
living in same area did not consider this insect a pest.
When Europeans moved in and began growing cultivated potatoes,
the insects moved from the wild plants to cultivated plants.
Partly due to removal of wild plants and partly to the fact
that human cultivars were far more plentiful. Once in the
cultivated crops, it immediately became a pest. Today, it
remains a major pest of potatoes in the U.S. and also attacks
a variety of related solanaceous plants including tobacco,
peppers, and eggplant. Also was transported to Europe and
moved quite quickly.
3. The alfalfa butterfly, a California native that fed on
scattered wild legumes, was once quite rare, but the widespread
cultivation of alfalfa throughout the state has made it
a common sight and a pest.
4. Monocultures. Planting vast areas with certain plants-like
fields of corn, soybeans etc.. Monocultures usually support
a simpler community of predators and parasites than would
be found in natural plant community. The pest populations
are highly unstable, like those seen in simple natural ecosystems.
Cultivation of a single species of plant increases the ease
with which herbivores that feed upon it can locate food
and competition is reduced.
C. Transport across a natural barrier
1. Often there is something about a new environment that
allows a species to increase in numbers much more rapidly
once it has become established there than it did in its
place of origin. Frequently, the imported species are not
pests in their place of origin because of various environmental
constrains and natural enemies.
2. Example: Importation of acacia tree from Australia because
it is a fine ornamental plant used extensively in dry conditions
of California summers. Brought in during Civil War and along
with it a tiny scale insect. Either the scale was unseen
or not thought to be important. Scale is called cottony
cushion scale and is not a serious pest in Australia.
a. Scale insects are strange. They have sucking mouthparts
and are true bugs Order Hemiptera) that are sap-suckers.
They build a shell over themselves which is basically their
cuticle and then glue themselves down to prevent predation.
b. When an insect is transported to a new area, it is likely
that no parasites or predators are present that specialize
on and can keep the insect in check. Often, populations
swing upwards. If the insect has a taste for a human crop,
then problems begin. For the cottony cushion scale, that
crop is citrus fruit. Within 20 years of import, 95% of
the citrus industry in California was eliminated due to
scale damage.
c. By 1888, the industry had just about vanished, when several
natural predators were imported from Australia to attempt
biological control. The Vedalia beetle, similar in appearance
to out Ladybugs, reduced the scale sufficiently to allow
citrus to be a major crop by the turn of the century.
3. Example: the European Corn Borer was imported to the
U.S. in broom corn, probably from Hungary, where it is not
a serious pest. Over its native range it can complete only
one generation per year and has a complex of native parasites
and predators. Following its introduction into the U.S.,
it spread rapidly in the absence of natural enemies and
became established throughout corn-growing areas of the
country. After
a period of about 20 years, a second generation of corn
borers began to appear in some of the warm areas.
4. Many times, species have been purposely introduced to
new areas in the belief they will provide benefits. The
gypsy moth was imported to Massachusetts from Europe in
1869 by a naturalist who hoped to crossbreed the hardy moth
with the silkworm moth to establish a new textile industry.
The gypsy moth escaped to become one of the most dreaded
pests in the eastern U.S. Larvae of this species can defoliate
many different types of trees. Vast sums are being spent
in an attempt to contain the pest.
5. Other Introductions:
a. Japanese Beetle (1920 from Japan)
b. Yellow fever mosquito (1600s from Africa)
c. Manduca sexta (1641 from Central America)
d. Phylloxera (1860s to Europe)
e. Asian tiger mosquito (1980's from Japan)
f. Asian long-horned beetle (1980s from ?)
6. The biology of invasive exotic species is a growing discipline.
These are some of the important research questions people
are asking.
o Can species be ranked based on their potential success
as invaders?
o Are some biotic communities and landscapes more vulnerable
to invasion than others; if
so, can we predict future invasion risks to different communities?
o Do current resource management practices pre-condition
ecosystems for invaders?
o At what stages of an invasion are management actions most
likely to be effective?
o What strategies can be used to detect invasions early
enough that there is still a chance of eradication?
o What are the economic costs of biotic invasions, and how
do these costs relate to the economic benefits associated
with increased global trade?
o What mitigation strategies are both effective and economically
practical once invaders become firmly established?
D. Insecticide use
1. Insecticides are supposed to kill pests, not create them.
2. Some insect species are more resistant to insecticides
than others.
3. Cottony cushion scale was controlled by Vedalia beetle
until late 1940's when DDT became available. The Vedalia
beetle was wiped out but the CCS, being under a layer of
skeleton and glued to trees, was less susceptible. It resurged
and nearly ruined the industry again.
4. The moral is: if the destruction of the target pest is
accompanied by the destruction of most of the target's natural
enemies there may be a rapid rebound in the pest population.
Pests may have higher fecundity/generation times.
E. Economic expectations
1. Damage from insects only means something if tied to monetary
value of crop. Crop production costs include a multitude
of things. If the goods are more attractive, there will
be more sales. Beginning in the 1950s, the growers were
able to deliver fruit that looked spectacular. We as consumers
grew accustomed to the aesthetic nature of the fruit and
ignored the hidden costs to the environment of constant
application of pesticide.
2. A nonpest of 50 years ago is now a pest because it ruins
the aesthetic look of a fruit. It does not in any way reduce
the quality of the food.
|